Rating Criteria Guide for AI Photo Editing Tools
Output Quality & Resolution
- 1–2: Low-res exports only, poor clarity, visible distortions.
- 3–4: Basic resolution, noticeable artifacts. Not suitable for professional use.
- 5–6: Acceptable quality for casual use, but lacks sharpness or natural finish.
- 7–8: High-quality outputs, crisp edges, good color accuracy.
- 9: Studio-grade clarity, excellent sharpness, minimal artifacts.
- 10: Flawless, professional-grade results, indistinguishable from manual editing.
Ease of Use (UI/UX)
- 1–2: Extremely complex, unintuitive interface. Hard learning curve.
- 3–4: Clunky workflow, limited guidance or help resources.
- 5–6: Usable with effort; tutorials or trial-and-error needed.
- 7–8: Intuitive editor, drag-and-drop, guided AI suggestions.
- 9: Smooth workflow, minimal friction, beginner-friendly onboarding.
- 10: Outstanding UX — seamless, AI-assisted, zero learning curve.
Core AI Features
- 1–2: Very limited (only 1–2 features like background removal).
- 3–4: A few basic tools (retouching, filters) but lack depth.
- 5–6: Decent set of features (background/object removal, skin retouching).
- 7–8: Wide coverage — advanced auto-retouch, inpainting, multiple AI modes.
- 9: Comprehensive suite with creative AI features (style transfer, generative fill).
- 10: Industry-leading, cutting-edge AI toolkit covering all editing needs.
Speed & Performance
- 1–2: Very slow, long wait times, unusable for high-res images.
- 3–4: Noticeable lag, acceptable only for small files.
- 5–6: Moderate speed, not instant but workable.
- 7–8: Fast processing, supports batch editing, minimal delays.
- 9: Near-instant edits, smooth on large files.
- 10: Real-time processing, no perceptible lag, scalable batch workflow.
Pricing & Plans
- 1–2: Overpriced, harsh limits, no free trial.
- 3–4: Free plan exists but very restrictive; expensive upgrades.
- 5–6: Average pricing, plans somewhat limited.
- 7–8: Fair pricing, good free plan or trial, transparent caps.
- 9: Great value — affordable, generous usage, hidden costs minimal.
- 10: Best-in-class pricing — excellent free tier, fair premium plans, no restrictions.
Rating Weightage Table (Sample)
| Parameter | Weight | Rating | Weighted Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Output Quality & Resolution | 35% | 9 | 3.15 |
| Ease of Use (UI/UX) | 25% | 8 | 2 |
| Core AI Features | 20% | 7 | 1.4 |
| Speed & Performance | 10% | 8 | 0.8 |
| Pricing & Plans | 10% | 7 | 0.7 |
| Overall Rating | 8.05 |
